go-Digital Blog on Digital Marketing

Facebook advertising metrics and benchmarks

Summary

Facebook click-through rates of 0.01 – 0.05% (Facebook CTRs)

Facebook effective CPMs turned out to be $0.01 – $0.19 (Facebook eCPMs)

Facebook average CPCs ranged from $0.05 – $0.25 (Facebook CPCs)

Other social media benchmarks from my experiments (Adwords, StumbleUpon, PayPerPost / Izea) can be found here.

As a scientist, I like to run experiments. And I like to make stuff. So my team and I made a few Facebook apps  that solved needs that we had (a few samples listed below) and shared them publicly on Facebook to see if they were also useful to other people too.

I beta tested some apps with a few friends by inviting them directly. Then to get it out to a larger number of people, we decided to try Facebook advertising, the much-hyped, holy grail of display advertising on one of the largest and most active social networks.

What we saw were click-through rates of 0.01 – 0.05% — and the 0.01% often seemed like rounding because they did not report more than 2 decimal places. As a result of these click rates the effective CPMs turned out to be $0.01 – $0.19 and average CPCs ranged from $0.05 – $0.25. I’ve been running these Facebook ads for more than 12 months; and millions of impresisons later, there is no observable improvements to CTRs and thus CPMs and CPCs. But since I set up the campaigns to only pay when there is a click (CPC basis), I can let these run indefinitely because I am getting so few clicks, it’s not even making a dent on my credit card (which I use to pay for the ads).

Ideas for Facebook

In the spirit of openness, as an advertiser who wants to continue using Facebook advertising, perhaps there are a few things they can do to improve the effectiveness of Facebook display ads.

Earth to Facebook…  anyone listening?

By Dr. Augustine Fou. Dr. Fou is Group Chief Digital Officer at Healthcare Consultancy Group a group of agencies within the Omnicom family specializing in pharma and healthcare.  He helps clients develop digital marketing programs or improve the efficiency and cost-effectiveness existing campaigns via advanced analytics, social marketing, and digital strategy. You can read more of his writing on digital marketing on this blog and follow him on twitter @acfou.

Revision 6/30/2009: Facebook Click Fraud

Excerpt from TechCrunch: “Click fraud is serious business on the big search engine advertising networks because the bad guys can make serious money. Sign up for an Adsense account and put those ads on parked domain names or wherever. Then all you have to do is start clicking those ads like crazy, using bots or cheap labor.” On Facebook, “advertisers are clicking on competitor ads to drive up their costs and drive down their ROI.”

“So the bad guys just create thousands of fake Facebook accounts with a wide variety of demographic information. This sounds like a lot of work, but it’s highly automated. the going rate was just $10 per 100 accounts if you supply the unique email accounts. Once the accounts are created, they use software to fill out the varied demographic information, and that software also manages all these accounts. The fraudster then logs in to Facebook via these accounts and views the ads that are displayed. The right competitive ads come up and Bingo, the software then clicks them. Facebook rules allow an account to click any advertisement up to six times in a 24 hour period, and all those clicks are charged. All you need is a few accounts to view the ads and then click to the max.”

http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/06/26/facebook-click-fraud-101/

http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/06/21/facebook-admit-click-fraud-problem-says-fix-coming-today/

Despite click fraud, the click through rates are still incredibly low. So if you subtract all the click fraud, is ANY advertiser making ANY money from facebook advertising?

Others have found similarly dismal click through rates from Facebook advertising

Source: http://www.friendswithbenefitsbook.com/2008/04/07/facebook-ad-click-through-rates-are-really-pitiful/

Facebook Ad Click-Through Rates Are Really Pitiful

April 7, 2008 – 5:03 pm

Quite by coincidence, I’ve encountered a few statistics on Facebook’s advertising platform. I thought I’d post links to the results I’ve uncovered, in case anybody is wondering about average CTR rates for Facebook.

First up, Rod Boothby got a click-through rate of 0.01%:

This week, I ran $105 worth of Facebook Fliers. That bought me 52,500 impressions. It looks like the flier bought me about an extra 500 site visits. That’s about $0.21 per hit.

Michael Ferguson ran a bunch of Facebook ads for Kinzin:

Click-through rates are abysmal. I was running the identical ad in about 15 different regions (you need to run them as separate ads to get the stats broken out), getting just over 10M views. Our average clickthrough rate was 0.06% (that’s 1 in 1513, for those counting at home). The best we did anywhere was 0.14%.

He later reports that the conversion rate was “at a pretty reasonable clip” at about 5%. By ‘conversion’, I think he’s meaning people who actually signed up for Kinzin’s free service. All of this stuff is contextual, but if visitors had to lay down money, the conversion rate would be considerably lower.

The folks at Valleywag report similarly dismal numbers:

Media buyers — the agency people who book campaigns — report that the college social network is a truly terrible target. They’re mainly students, with low disposable income, of course; but, beyond that, the users appear to be too busy leaving messages for eachother to show much interest in advertising. Facebook’s members appear indifferent even to movie advertising aimed at their demographic. Clickthrough rates, the percentage of time users click on an ad, average 0.04% — just 400 clicks in every 1m views — according to one report seen by Valleywag.

From AllFacebook:

Fred Wilson has been updating the world about his venture in Facebook advertising over the past week. Today, Fred posted and updated screenshot of his ad campaign’s performance and it doesn’t appear to be too stellar. For one of his campaigns, out of 10,080 impressions there were only 8 clicks. The average cost-per-click for Fred was $0.08 and the average CPM was $0.06. This is a less than stellar performance. This is nothing new though.

And lastly, from a digital student marketing blog in the UK. This would seem like a natural fit for Facebook’s audience:

Our most recent campaign saw 1.4 million page impressions delivered at specific universities – and only a 0.04% clickthrough rate. Ouch.

Click-through rates seem to sit around 0.04%, which is profoundly lame if you ask me. I’m no online advertising expert–it’s not really our thing–but I’ve run a bunch of Google AdWords and other contextual advertising campaigns. We regularly get click-through rates of 3%, and I gather that’s nothing special.

Here’s my theory on Facebook: it’s a silo. People visit the Fun House of Facebook, and conceptually treat it slightly different than the rest of the web. They’re in Facebook, interacting with friends, playing games, sending messages and now chatting on IM. As such, they’re really unmotivated to leave. Who wants to leave the Fun House?

We’ve seen similar results across Facebook. It’s really difficult to drive visitors out of the app and to your own website.

Tags: a good click through rate, Abysmal Click-Through Rates, advertisement on facebook statistics, advertising, advertising click-through benchmarking, Adwords, Amazon, apps, attention, automated click fraud, average click through rate for facebook, average cost per click for facebook, average CPC for Facebook, average CPCs, average ctr "LinkedIn", average ctr facebook 2009, average CTR on facebook ad network, average facebook campaign costs, backend, benchmarking in social marketing, benchmarks, beta, Chief Digital, circle, click, click farm, click fraud, click through rates on facebook ads, commerce, control, CPCs, CPMs, crm on facebook, CTR - Clickthrough Rates on Facebook CPC Ads, CTRs, decimal places, difference, digital marketing, discovery, display, display advertising, Dr. Fou, drag, drag and drop, e cards, effective cost per thousand for facebook, effective CPMs, effectiveness of facebook ads, Facebook, facebook ad benchmarks, facebook ad click through rate, facebook ad cpc, facebook ad effectiveness, facebook ad metrics, facebook ad rates, facebook ad specs, facebook ads Actions Rate, facebook ads CTR, facebook ads effectiveness, facebook ads impressions, facebook ads impressions vs clicks, facebook ads metrics, facebook advertising, facebook advertising clicks, facebook advertising costs, facebook advertising effectiveness, facebook advertising impressions, facebook advertising kpi, Facebook advertising metrics, facebook advertising rates, facebook average CPCs, facebook benchmarks, Facebook Click Fraud, facebook click through rates, Facebook CPCs, facebook CTR, Facebook CTRs, facebook display advertising, Facebook eCPMs, facebook effective CPMs, facebook good click through rate, facebook kpi, facebook marketing, facebook metrics, facebook statistics, facebook stats, faecbook metrics, flickr, Fraud, friend, good click through rate for facebook, grail, Group, healthcare, holy grail, how effective are facebook ads, how effective facebook advertising, hyped, increase your clickthrough rate on facebook, interface, is advertising on facebook effective, izea, lot, management, management interface, marketing, mass, metrics for facebook ads, music, Netflix, none, number, page, PayPerPost, photo, potential, promise, queue, reach, ROI, same time period, sample, scientist, search, share, So Few Clicks, So Many Ads, social actions, social ads, social marketing benchmarks, social media benchmarks, social media kpi, social media response rate benchmark, social networks, something, status, status updates, stuff, StumbleUpon, summary, team, time, topic, use, video, visual discovery, what are click rates for facebook ads, what is a good click through rate for facebook ads?, what is a good CTR on facebook, what is a good facebook click through rate, what is a good facebook ctr, whats a good click rate for facebook ads, YouTube